Personal Injury Judge Intelligence
PI outcomes are highly judge-sensitive. CCI profiles reveal how judges manage evidence, handle expert disputes, approach comparative fault arguments, and what damages benchmarks look like for your specific judge.
14-day free trial · No credit card required · Pro plan $49/month
Built for personal injury
Why Personal Injury Practitioners Love CCI
Damage award benchmarks: median verdicts and settlements by injury type and case value for each judge's department.
Expert admissibility patterns: how judges handle Sargon challenges, Daubert-equivalent scrutiny, and medical causation disputes.
Trial management intelligence: voir dire time, jury instructions disputes, and how actively judges intervene during trial.
Judge profiles
Top Personal Injury Judges
Profiles from the most-researched personal injury departments across California.
Judge Theresa M. Traber
Stanley Mosk Courthouse, Los Angeles
Judge Stephen M. Pulido
Hayward Hall of Justice, Hayward
Judge Benjamin T. Reyes, II
Wakefield Taylor Courthouse, Martinez
Judge Albert A. Erkel
Judge Jeffrey Erickson
Rancho Cucamonga Courthouse, Rancho Cucamonga
Judge Sunil R. Kulkarni
Downtown Superior Court, San Jose
What CCI tracks
Key Metrics for Personal Injury
Plaintiff Verdict Rate
How often plaintiff prevails at trial in the department — across all PI case types in the judge's history.
e.g., Plaintiff verdict in 61% of tried PI casesExpert Challenge Success Rate
How often Sargon / Daubert challenges to expert testimony succeed — by expert type (medical, economic, accident reconstruction).
e.g., Medical causation expert excluded in 18% of challengesNon-Economic Damages
Median non-economic damage awards by injury severity — compared to county-wide averages.
e.g., Median non-economic: $425K for soft tissue casesComparative Fault Application
How judges instruct on and juries apply comparative fault in this department — plaintiff vs. defendant assignment patterns.
e.g., Avg. 22% fault assigned to plaintiff in slip-and-fallStrategic intelligence
Personal Injury Strategy Guide
Practical guidance for using judge intelligence in personal injury practice.
Venue selection in PI cases should account for the judge's damage award history, not just plaintiff-friendly jury pools. A great jury in a defendant-friendly courtroom produces mixed results.
Sargon challenges are more effective before some judges than others. Review your judge's expert exclusion history before investing in a full challenge briefing.
Trial time limits vary dramatically. Some departments impose strict hour limits on each side; others are more permissive. Know your time allocation before you structure your case.
Settlement leverage calculations in PI cases must account for the judge's history of granting in limine motions that could significantly narrow what the jury hears.
Search judges
Find Personal Injury Judges
Showing 6 of 6 judges
Judge Theresa M. Traber
Stanley Mosk Courthouse, Los Angeles
Judge Stephen M. Pulido
Hayward Hall of Justice, Hayward
Judge Benjamin T. Reyes, II
Wakefield Taylor Courthouse, Martinez
Judge Albert A. Erkel
Judge Jeffrey Erickson
Rancho Cucamonga Courthouse, Rancho Cucamonga
Judge Sunil R. Kulkarni
Downtown Superior Court, San Jose
Learn more
Related Personal Injury Resources
Judge comparison tool
Compare Personal Injury Judges Head-to-Head
Select 2–4 judges and get a side-by-side comparison of ruling patterns, grant rates, risk flags, and AI-generated strategic analysis — in seconds.
Get started
Know your personal injury judge
Personal Injury outcomes are judge-dependent. Give yourself and your clients the intelligence advantage before every hearing.
14-day free trial · Pro plan $49/month · Cancel anytime