Appellate Judge Intelligence
Appellate practice requires different intelligence than trial court work. CCI covers California Courts of Appeal patterns, writ petition grant rates, oral argument tendencies, and how individual appellate courts approach specific issue areas.
14-day free trial · No credit card required · Pro plan $49/month
Built for appellate
Why Appellate Practitioners Love CCI
Writ petition grant rates by district and division: which divisions are receptive to mandate petitions and on what grounds extraordinary relief is most often granted.
Oral argument intelligence: which appellate panels regularly set argument on submitted matters, how much time each justice typically uses, and what questions signal skepticism.
Briefing standards and tendencies: how individual appellate justices approach waiver arguments, forfeiture, and whether they are receptive to supplemental authority letters.
Judge profiles
Top Appellate Judges
Profiles from the most-researched appellate departments across California.
Judge Theresa M. Traber
Stanley Mosk Courthouse, Los Angeles
Judge Stephen M. Pulido
Hayward Hall of Justice, Hayward
Judge Benjamin T. Reyes, II
Wakefield Taylor Courthouse, Martinez
Judge Albert A. Erkel
Judge Jeffrey Erickson
Rancho Cucamonga Courthouse, Rancho Cucamonga
Judge Sunil R. Kulkarni
Downtown Superior Court, San Jose
What CCI tracks
Key Metrics for Appellate
Writ Petition Grant Rate
Alternative writ issuance rates by district and division — disaggregated by type (mandate, prohibition, supersedeas, habeas).
e.g., Alternative writ issued in 12% of mandate petitionsOral Argument Set Rate
How often appellate panels set oral argument on calendared cases vs. submitting on the briefs.
e.g., Oral argument set in 34% of civil appeals in Division XReversal Rate by Issue Type
Court-specific reversal rates disaggregated by issue category — instructional error, evidentiary rulings, sufficiency of evidence.
e.g., Reversal rate on instructional error: 28% in Division IVAttorney Fee Award on Appeal
How often prevailing appellants and respondents recover fees on appeal — and what fee application standards apply.
e.g., Fees on appeal awarded in 61% of FEHA reversalsStrategic intelligence
Appellate Strategy Guide
Practical guidance for using judge intelligence in appellate practice.
Writ practice requires knowing the division before you file. Some appellate divisions are receptive to mandate petitions on discovery orders; others almost never grant alternative writs on interlocutory issues.
Oral argument preparation should be tailored to each justice's questioning style. Research prior argument recordings and recent opinions to understand what each panelist finds most important.
Forfeiture and waiver arguments are dispositive in some appellate divisions and largely ignored in others. Know how your division treats below-the-line objections before you argue any appellate issue.
Supplemental authority letters under California Rules of Court 8.254 are used differently by different divisions. Some welcome recent authority; others disfavor them absent significant precedential changes.
Search judges
Find Appellate Judges
Showing 6 of 6 judges
Judge Theresa M. Traber
Stanley Mosk Courthouse, Los Angeles
Judge Stephen M. Pulido
Hayward Hall of Justice, Hayward
Judge Benjamin T. Reyes, II
Wakefield Taylor Courthouse, Martinez
Judge Albert A. Erkel
Judge Jeffrey Erickson
Rancho Cucamonga Courthouse, Rancho Cucamonga
Judge Sunil R. Kulkarni
Downtown Superior Court, San Jose
Learn more
Related Appellate Resources
Judge comparison tool
Compare Appellate Judges Head-to-Head
Select 2–4 judges and get a side-by-side comparison of ruling patterns, grant rates, risk flags, and AI-generated strategic analysis — in seconds.
Get started
Know your appellate judge
Appellate outcomes are judge-dependent. Give yourself and your clients the intelligence advantage before every hearing.
14-day free trial · Pro plan $49/month · Cancel anytime