Judge Anne Kiley

Judge Anne Kiley is a relatively newly appointed jurist on the Los Angeles Superior Court's family law bench, having received her appointment from Governor Gavin Newsom on December 7, 2023. Her background is distinctly specialized: she spent her pre-bench career as a private family law attorney in Los Angeles, earning recognition from The Hollywood Reporter in November 2022 as one of the top 35 lawyers in Hollywood for matters involving death, divorce, and other legal challenges. This recognition signals that she handled high-stakes, high-conflict, and often high-net-worth family law matters before ascending to the bench. Notably, she also served as a private judge — most visibly in the Jolie-Pitt divorce proceedings — which suggests she has experience managing complex, contentious, and media-sensitive cases with discretion and procedural rigor. The descriptors consistently applied to Judge Kiley in public coverage — efficiency, empathy, and experience — are not merely promotional language. They reflect a judicial philosophy likely shaped by years of representing clients through some of the most emotionally and financially complex disputes imaginable. Attorneys should expect a judge who understands the human stakes of family law proceedings deeply, but who also prizes procedural efficiency and dislikes unnecessary delay or posturing. Her Daily Journal profile from March 2025 reinforces this dual emphasis on compassion and practicality. Because Judge Kiley comes from the practitioner side of family law rather than from a general litigation or prosecutorial background, she is likely to have strong intuitions about when attorneys are over-litigating, padding billable hours, or using procedural tactics to harass opposing parties. Her private judge experience further suggests comfort with complex asset structures, custody disputes involving public figures, and high-conflict dynamics — all of which she likely approaches with a results-oriented, settlement-encouraging disposition.

Attorneys appearing before Judge Kiley should lead with practical, solution-oriented arguments rather than purely adversarial posturing. Given her background as a top family law practitioner and private judge, she will quickly identify when an attorney is inflating conflict rather than resolving it. Frame your arguments around the best interests of children (in custody matters) and equitable outcomes (in asset division matters) with concrete factual support. Avoid rhetorical excess — she has likely heard every emotional appeal imaginable and will be more moved by well-organized evidence and clear legal authority. Efficiency is a core value for Judge Kiley. Come to hearings fully prepared, with concise briefs, organized exhibits, and a clear roadmap of what you are asking the court to do and why. Do not use court time to educate yourself on the record — she will expect you to know your case cold. If you have a complex financial matter, consider retaining a forensic accountant or financial expert early and presenting their conclusions clearly. Her experience with high-net-worth cases means she is comfortable with sophisticated financial arguments, but she will expect them to be presented efficiently. Given her empathy-forward reputation, attorneys representing vulnerable parties — particularly those involving domestic violence allegations, child welfare concerns, or significant power imbalances — should not shy away from presenting the human context of their client's situation. However, this should be done with evidentiary support, not melodrama. Conversely, attorneys on the opposing side of such claims should be prepared for a judge who takes protective orders and child safety arguments seriously and will not dismiss them lightly.

• critical

  Prepare Concise, Issue-Specific Briefs

  Given Judge Kiley's emphasis on efficiency, draft briefs that are tightly organized around specific legal issues with clear headings, concise argument sections, and direct requests for relief. Avoid padding. She will likely read closely and expect precision.

• critical

  Organize Financial Evidence With Expert Support

  For asset division, support, or business valuation matters, retain a qualified forensic accountant or financial expert early. Prepare clear summaries of complex financial structures. Her high-net-worth practitioner background means she will scrutinize financial presentations carefully.

• important

  Document Settlement Efforts Thoroughly

  Before any contested hearing, ensure your file reflects genuine good-faith settlement efforts. Given her likely settlement-encouraging disposition, demonstrating that your client attempted resolution may influence her approach to fee awards and procedural rulings.

• important

  Research Her Recent Tentative Rulings and Orders

  As she builds her record on the bench (appointed December 2023), monitor the Stanley Mosk family law department for any published tentative rulings, minute orders, or reported decisions to identify emerging patterns in her decision-making before your appearance.

• important

  Prepare Child-Centered Arguments in Custody Matters

  In any custody or visitation dispute, frame arguments explicitly around the best interests of the child with specific factual support. Her empathy-forward reputation suggests she will be particularly attentive to how each party's position serves or harms the children involved.

• Nice

  Anticipate Judicial Questions on Proportionality

  Be prepared to justify the proportionality of your litigation approach — why the motions filed, discovery sought, or hearings requested are necessary and not excessive. A judge who prizes efficiency will want to understand why court resources are being consumed.

• ›Arrive fully prepared with organized exhibits, a clear outline of requested relief, and complete knowledge of your record — Judge Kiley's efficiency emphasis means she will expect counsel to use court time productively, not to get up to speed.
• ›Maintain a respectful, non-combative tone toward opposing counsel in the courtroom. Her empathy-oriented philosophy and family law background suggest she is attuned to interpersonal dynamics and may view unnecessary hostility between counsel as a negative signal about a party's good faith.
• ›Be direct and concise when addressing the court. Avoid lengthy preambles, repetitive argument, or emotional appeals unsupported by evidence. She has heard it all as a practitioner and private judge — get to the point with factual and legal precision.
• ›If you represent a party in a high-profile or media-sensitive matter, be scrupulous about confidentiality and avoid any suggestion that litigation strategy is being driven by public relations considerations. Her Jolie-Pitt experience suggests she is alert to this dynamic.
• ›When the court signals it has heard enough on a point, stop arguing. Experienced family law judges who value efficiency will not respond well to counsel who cannot read the room or who repeat arguments already made.